A restaurant review, a scam-alert video naming a seller, a reply under another creator's post, a repost of a rumour: each can bring a legal notice. Defamation is one of the most common legal risks for people who publish opinions online, and it works in both directions. A creator can be accused of it, and a creator can be the victim of it.
What counts as defamation?
In broad terms, defamation is publishing a statement about a person that harms, or is intended or known to be likely to harm, that person's reputation. Publication includes a video, a caption, a story, a comment, a reply and a repost. It is both a civil wrong, for which a court can award damages and grant an injunction, and a criminal offence. Criminal defamation is now in Section 356 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), which replaced Sections 499 and 500 of the Indian Penal Code from 1 July 2024. The Supreme Court upheld the constitutional validity of criminal defamation in Subramanian Swamy v. Union of India (2016). The punishment under the BNS can include simple imprisonment of up to two years, a fine, both, or community service.
Fact, opinion and the exceptions
The law protects some kinds of statement even if they hurt a reputation. The statute lists exceptions, and the main ones that matter to creators are:
- Truth, where publishing it is for the public good. Truth alone is not always enough, and it has to be provable.
- An opinion in good faith on the conduct of a public servant, or on a public question.
- An honest opinion on the merits of a work or performance that has been put before the public, which is the basis of a fair review.
- A statement made in good faith to protect your own interest or the public interest, within limits.
The practical lesson is to separate what you can prove from what you think. 'The food was cold and the service took an hour' is a statement you can support. 'The owner is a fraud who cheats customers' is a serious allegation of fact, and if you cannot prove it, the exceptions will not help. Phrases such as 'in my opinion' do not turn an unsupported factual allegation into protected opinion.
Where creators get into trouble
- Scam-alert and exposé videos that name an individual or business without documents to support the claim.
- Reviews that allege dishonesty, illegality or a medical or safety risk, as opposed to describing your own experience.
- Call-out videos aimed at another creator, particularly where the video includes edited clips or unverified screenshots.
- Reposting, quote-posting or sharing a rumour. Your repost is your own publication.
- Replying to or pinning a comment that makes a serious allegation, which can be treated as adopting it.
If you receive a legal notice or complaint
- Keep a copy of the post, the date, the URL and any comments and edits. Do not rely on the platform to keep them.
- Read the notice for what exactly is said to be defamatory, what it demands and by when.
- Do not reply in anger, post a counter-attack, or contact the sender's customers or family. Those steps usually make the position worse.
- Take advice before deleting the post. Removal can limit the harm and be seen as reasonable conduct, but a deletion made without keeping a copy leaves you without your own evidence.
- Collect the material that supports your statement: invoices, messages, photographs, screenshots with dates, or the sources you relied on.
- A properly worded reply, a correction or a clarification can end the matter. A court may also take a prompt, genuine apology into account.
If a creator or business is defaming you
- Preserve evidence with the URL, date, time and account name. A screen recording of the post and its comments helps.
- Report the content to the platform under its defamation or harassment policy. Platforms act on their own rules and are not courts.
- Send a legal notice stating the false statements, why they are false, and what you require, such as removal, a correction and an apology.
- Consider a civil suit for an injunction and damages. A court can order removal, and High Courts have granted urgent interim orders in clear cases.
- Consider a criminal complaint under Section 356 of the BNS where the facts justify it. Courts look hard at whether the complaint is a genuine one or pressure.
A civil claim for defamation generally has to be filed within one year of publication, so delay can end the claim. Platforms that host content are intermediaries. After Shreya Singhal v. Union of India (2015), which struck down Section 66A of the Information Technology Act, a platform is generally required to remove content on a court order or a government direction, and it may also act under its own policies and the IT Rules.
A creator wrongly accused of a crime in a complaint that is itself based on a false allegation may also have remedies; see our guide on taking action against a person who files a false case.
Further reading
This article is general legal information about Indian law, published to educate and not to advise on any individual case or to solicit work. Laws, rules and platform policies change; verify the current position before acting. Reading it does not create an advocate–client relationship.

