Skip to main content
MDR Law & Associates

Copyright & Content Ownership · Practical guide

Reaction, Review and Commentary Videos: Where Fair Dealing Ends and Copyright Infringement Begins

By MDR Law & Associates · 15 November 2026 · 7 min read

A reaction video shows a creator watching a trailer, a song or someone else's video and commenting on it. A review or commentary channel plays clips to analyse them. These formats are popular, and so are the notices they attract. The law does allow some use of other people's works for criticism and review, but the allowance is narrower than many creators assume.

Section 52(1)(a) of the Copyright Act, 1957 says that a fair dealing with a work, other than a computer programme, for the purposes of private or personal use, criticism or review (of that work or of any other work), or reporting current events and current affairs, is not an infringement. India does not use the broader American fair use test. The question is whether the dealing is fair and whether it is for one of the listed purposes. A parody, a mere compilation or a general entertainment video does not fit automatically into any of them.

What courts tend to look at

  • The purpose. Is the use really criticism or review, or is the other person's work simply being shown to attract viewers?
  • The amount. How much of the work is used, and whether the extract is the heart of the work.
  • The effect on the original. Whether viewers can watch your video instead of the original, so that the owner loses an audience or a licence fee.
  • The commentary. Whether your own analysis runs through the clip, or the clip plays with a few reactions over it.
  • Acknowledgement of the source and whether the use is commercial.

These are general considerations drawn from how courts have approached fair dealing, and no single factor decides a case. A short clip with sustained critical comment is on much firmer ground than the full song with a face-cam in a corner.

Lower-risk and higher-risk practices

  • Lower risk: short extracts, tied to specific points of criticism, with the commentary doing most of the work and the source named.
  • Lower risk: describing, scoring or discussing a work without playing it in full.
  • Higher risk: playing a full song, scene, match highlight or video with brief reactions.
  • Higher risk: using the most valuable part of the work, such as a climax, a song's hook or the punchline.
  • Higher risk: using content from paid or subscription sources, or from a competitor creator, in a way that stands in for it.
  • Higher risk: adding music, footage or images owned by other people that you do not need for the comment.

Platform rules are separate from the law

A platform can claim, mute, demonetise or remove a video even when the use might be fair dealing, because its process is automated and its policies are its own. Fair dealing is a defence in court, and it does not stop a Content ID claim. Our guides on YouTube copyright strikes and wrong Content ID claims explain how to respond.

Other risks in commentary

A review that makes serious factual allegations about a person or business can raise defamation issues; see online defamation risks for creators. Using someone's name or logo in a way that suggests a connection can raise trademark concerns, and paid reviews must be disclosed; see our guide on advertising disclosure rules.

A practical checklist

  1. Decide the purpose: what point of criticism or review is each clip supporting?
  2. Use the least of the work you need to make that point.
  3. Talk over and about the clip throughout, with real analysis.
  4. Name the source and link to it in the description.
  5. Remove or replace third-party music and images that you do not need.
  6. Keep your notes and a copy of the edit. If you are challenged, they show what you intended and how you used the work.

This article is general legal information about Indian law, published to educate and not to advise on any individual case or to solicit work. Laws, rules and platform policies change; verify the current position before acting. Reading it does not create an advocate–client relationship.

Quick answers

Frequently asked questions

Is a reaction video always fair dealing?

No. It depends on whether you are genuinely criticising or reviewing the work, how much you use, and whether your video replaces the original.

Does crediting the original creator make it legal?

No. Acknowledgement helps show good faith, but it is not a substitute for permission or a fair dealing exception.

Can I be sued if my video is monetised?

Monetisation does not itself make use unfair, but commercial use is one of the factors a court may weigh. Where the use is not fair dealing, the owner may seek an injunction, damages or an account of profits.

Related legal service

Intellectual Property Rights for Creators

Copyright, trademark and brand-name protection, and action against copying and piracy.

Related guides

YouTube & Platform Disputes · Practical guide

Received a YouTube Copyright Strike? What an Indian Creator Should Do

A copyright strike can restrict a channel and repeated strikes can end it. This guide explains the difference between a strike and a Content ID claim, your options, and how Indian copyright law applies to the content you use.

15 November 2026 · 8 min read